Karen M. Overtoom Logo
Your connection to all Martha's Vineyard Real Estate and Vacation Rentals
508-693-7832
Karen M. Overtoom Logo
508-693-7832

The Best of Fall Dining on the Vineyard!


Fall on the Vineyard is the perfect time to get out and enjoy the local restaurants that now have space for us all! There is a plentitude of dinning island wide for every palate. Bon Appetite!

Edgartown:

Alchemy - Open 5 Nights a Week at 5:30pm, Closed Wednesdays & Sundays - try the Crispy Oysters and Wagyu Burger with a Fallen Fruit gin cocktail and enjoy the hopping atmosphere. 

Bettini at the Harborview Hotel - Open 7 Days a Week! Breakfast 7:30am - Last Seating at 10:30am - Dinner, Seven Days a Week, 5:00pm - Last Seating at 9:00pm - Beautiful views of the harbor light and Chappy - Try the Local Crab Cake and any of the homemade pastas! 

The Newes from America – Tuesday-Saturday, 12pm - 10pm - Reuben and a bag of onion rings!

Town Bar & Grill - Closed Wednesdays - Tuesday night trivia! Fish & Chips & Bang Bang Shrimp!

Oak Bluffs:

The Barn & Bistro - Open for lunch & dinner Tuesday-Saturday from 11:30am-9:30pm, and Mondays for lunch only 11:30am-4pm. Closed on Sundays. Bowling is only available in the evening starting at 5pm. Try the shaved brussels & kale salad and the fried chicken! Stay for a round of bowling!

The Cardboard Box - Tuesday-Saturday 5pm-10pm - takeout, indoor and outdoor dining. Fried oysters & fried chicken! 

Deon's Kitchen - Sunday-Friday 12:30pm-9pm - takeout and indoor dining. Goat Curry, Braised Oxtail Dinner, & Vegetarian Delight - EVERYTHING is amazing. 

Dilly’s at the Ritz - FOOD Tues-Sun 11:30AM- 8:30PM - LIVE MUSIC IS BACK! - OPEN FOR FOOD DRINKS & GOOD TIMES - Tues-Sun 11:30AM-1AM. Live music most nights. 

The Food Truck at the MV Arena - Lemon Rosemary Fries are BACK! Look for their daily specials. 

Lookout Tavern - Dinner: Sunday-Thursday 4pm – 9:30pm, Fri & Sat   4pm – 10pm, Lunch: Fri-Sat-Sun 11:30am – 4:00pm - Overlook the Oak Bluffs harbor while feasting on sushi and more!

Vineyard Haven:

Beach Road - Monday through Saturday 5pm-9pm, closed Sundays. Burger Night on Mondays!! Try the “Toast” and Bouillabaisse!!

Copper Wok -  Monday through Saturday 4:30pm-9:30pm – Samosas, Sushi, Pad Thai!

Little House – Monday-Friday 7am-7:30pm, Saturday 8am-7:30pm - French Lentil Salad and the Chicken Shawarma Wrap! 

Pie Chicks - Window hours Tuesday-Saturday, 8am-4pm or until sellout - Coffee, Baked Goods, Quiche and pre-ordered pie. 

Salvatore’s Ristorante Italiano - Open 5pm-9pm, Closed Tuesdays & Wednesdays - Outside/Inside Dinning & Curbside Pick-up! Our favorite meal? Quattro di Bruschetta, Pappardelle al filleto di manzo, & Tiramisu. Always order the Saltimbocca and Squash Blossoms when they pop up on the specials menu! Amazing wine and mixed drinks menu, save room for the Tiramisu and Limoncello.

Tansy Tea & Coffee - Monday through Saturday, from 8am-3pm - A new luncheonette in the Tisbury Market Place that’s taking a different approach to your everyday beverage and light bite.

Up-island:

7a Foods - Open 8am-2pm, Please call 508-693-4636. Liz Lemon is the local favorite. 

The Grey Barn and Farm - OPEN 8am-5pm - closed Tuesdays & Wednesdays. Farm made breads, cheeses, eggs, meat, milk, & veg. 

Orange Peel Bakery - Pizza Thursday nights from 5-7:30pm - Please call for bakery and pizza night - (508) 645-2025

Thanksgiving Dining Options:

Bettini Restaurant - Five-course dinner. Pre-order take out will also be available. Call to make a reservation 774-563-5205.

The Black Dog Tavern - Three-course sit-down dinner ($60: Person) with seatings at noon, 2 p.m. and 4 p.m. Call to make a reservation: 508-693-9223

Black Sheep - Order from an à la carte Thanksgiving menu by Nov. 15: 508-338-7770

Edgartown Meat & Fish Market - Order a turkey from Misty Knoll Farms. 508-627-6200

The Fish House - Order a turkey from Misty Knoll Farms by Nov. 7. 508-693-0055

Juice by the Sea - Order from an à la carte Thanksgiving menu by Nov. 17. 508-338-2920

Katama General Store - Order from an à la carte Thanksgiving menu by Nov. 12.

Kitchen Porch Catering - Order an organic pasture raised turkey. Pick up on Nov. 22 from 10 a.m. to noon.

Morning Glory Farm - Order from an à la carte Thanksgiving menu by Nov. 22 at 6 a.m.; order fresh turkeys by Nov. 12.

Pie Chicks Bakery - Order pies. 508-693-0228

Scottish Bakehouse - Order from an à la carte Thanksgiving menu by Nov. 22. 508-693-6633

Tigerhawk Sandwich Co. - Order a Thanksgiving dinner ($60: Person). 508-338-7306